The Role of Risk Assumption in the Legal Framework of Mistake Regarding the Subject Matter of a Contract

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Professor, Private and Ecomomic Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Allameh Tabataba’i University, Tehran, Iran

2 Ph.D Student, Private Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Allameh Tabataba’i University, Tehran, Iran Iran

Abstract
1. Introduction
Every contract is based on a set of assumptions and mental perceptions of the parties regarding reality; perceptions that serve as the motive and foundation for the decision to conclude an agreement. These beliefs, which can be mutual or unilateral, concern various dimensions of the contract, including the subject matter, the identity of the counterparty, the purpose, and the governing regulations. Occasionally, these perceptions do not align with reality, creating difficulties in contractual relations that have led to the formation of the complex topic of "mistake" in contract law. In the Iranian legal system, the rules governing mistake are primarily justified based on the impairment of intention and consent. However, it appears that this foundation alone cannot adequately cover all dimensions and complexities of the issue, particularly in modern commercial relations. Managing uncertainty and allocating risk between the parties is an important function of a contract. Analyzing the doctrine of mistake without considering how the parties have allocated the risk of discrepancy between reality and their perceptions would be incomplete. When parties transact in an environment of uncertainty with awareness of their imperfect information, or when they expressly assume the potential consequences of an error, their perceptions are formed not on certainty but on the basis of probabilities. In such a scenario, the discovery that their perceptions were mistaken is the realization of a risk they had previously assumed.
2. Literature Review
Legal logic and the necessity of transactional stability dictate that if a party has assumed the risk of mistake, either expressly (e.g., through exemption clauses) or impliedly (by implication of custom, the nature of the transaction, or acting in a state of doubt), they cannot annul the contract by invoking the doctrine of mistake. This logic has led leading legal systems, such as those of the United States and France, as well as international documents like the UNIDROIT Principles and the Principles of European Contract Law (PECL), to recognize the "non-assumption of risk" as a fundamental condition for invoking mistake. In Iranian law, however, this condition has not been explicitly stated under its specific title in statutory texts and doctrine. Despite the fundamental importance of this topic, no comprehensive research has yet been conducted on the feasibility of applying the rule of risk assumption to contractual mistakes within the context of Iranian law. The innovative aspect of the present research lies in addressing these neglected considerations regarding risk assumption, which can reveal new and different dimensions of the debate on mistake in legal literature.
3. Materials and Methods
The present research employed a descriptive–analytical method. It also relied on library sources to collect the data and present the discussion.
4. Results and Discussion
The research findings indicate that, contrary to initial assumptions, the Iranian legal system is not alien to the concept of risk assumption in contractual mistakes. Rather, this concept is actively present through traditional and indigenous institutions such as the "waiver of options" (isqāt-al-khiyārāt) and the "rule of action/assumption of risk" (qā'idah al-iqdām). The primary challenge arises when the broad application of this theory sometimes requires entering into a transaction with a degree of ignorance and uncertainty regarding the subject matter, which initially appears to conflict with the rule of "prohibition of gharar." This conflict, particularly concerning mistakes about the fundamental conditions for the validity of a contract (such as economic value and deliverability), can lead to the invalidation of rational and efficient commercial contracts. For example, if a marine salvage expert purchases a stranded ship at a very low price, fully aware of the risk that refloating it might be impossible, and subsequently fails in the salvage operation, their invocation of the lack of deliverability and the subsequent nullity of the sale lacks economic justification. This is because the expert buyer assumed the risk of their perception being mistaken, and this risk was reflected in the contract price.
The research findings indicate that the widespread acceptance of aleatory and risk-based contracts in Islamic jurisprudence and statutory law (such as insurance, ju'ālah, and partnership contracts) indicates that gharar is a "customary" concept influenced by economic necessities. Not every risk or instance of ignorance constitutes gharar. Prohibited gharar is a risk that custom deems intolerable and gambling-like (a zero-sum game). However, if entering a transaction with ignorance is based on skill, expertise, commercial calculations, and value creation, and uncertainty is considered an inherent part of the economic essence of the transaction, the nature of the act shifts to a "reasonable risky investment" (a positive-sum game) that the legal system must recognize as valid.
5. Conclusion
In conclusion, it can be stated that within the framework of the current regulations of the Iranian legal system, and relying on the rule of iqdām, the waiver of options, and most importantly, a precise and customary interpretation of the concept of gharar, the rule of "assumption of risk of mistake" can be applied and justified. To ensure the stability and security of transactional relations, it is recommended that, based on distinguishing "invalidating gharar" from "legitimate risk" in cases such as mistake in economic value or deliverability, if it is established that the parties consciously assumed uncertainty in a rational context and based on expertise, the matter should be excluded from the scope of invalidating gharar and the realm of mistake. Nevertheless, it is appropriate for the Iranian legislature, in alignment with leading legal systems, to explicitly stipulate the "non-assumption of risk" as a statutory condition for invoking mistake.

Keywords

Subjects

In Persian
Books
- Emami, Hasan, Civil Law, Vol. 1, 27th ed., (Tehran: Eslamiyeh, 2007). [In Persian]
- Ansari, Mehdi, Economic Analysis of Contract Law, 1st ed., (Tehran: Javdaneh, 2011). [In Persian]
- Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jafar, Basis in Civil Laws: Al-Mudawwanah, 1st ed., (Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh, 2008). [In Persian]
- Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jafar, Al-Fariq: General Encyclopedia of Civil Law, Vol. 2, 1st ed., (Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh, 2007). [In Persian]
- Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jafar, Al-Fariq: General Encyclopedia of Law, Vol. 4 (Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh, 2007). [In Persian]
- Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jafar, Thought and Elevation (Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh, 2008). [In Persian]
- Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jafar, Supreme Philosophy in the Science of Law (Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh, 2003). [In Persian]
- Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jafar, Philosophy of Civil Law, General Elements of Contracts, Vol. 1 (Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh, 2001). [In Persian]
- Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jafar, Vasit in Law Terminology (Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh, 2009). [In Persian]
- Shahidi, Mehdi, Formation of Contracts and Obligations, Vol. 2, 1st ed., (Tehran: Hoghoughdan, 1998). [In Persian]
- Safaei, Hossein, General Rules of Contracts, 5th ed., (Tehran: Mizan, 2007). [In Persian]
- Katouzian, Nasser, Specific Contracts, Vol. 1, 12th ed., (Tehran: Enteshar Corp, 2013). [In Persian]
- Katouzian, Nasser, General Rules of Contracts, Vol. 1, 8th ed., (Tehran: Enteshar Corp, 2009). [In Persian]
- Katouzian, Nasser, General Rules of Contracts, Vol. 5, 8th ed., (Tehran: Enteshar Corp, 2014). [In Persian]
- Katouzian, Nasser, General Rules of Contracts, Vol. 2, 3rd ed., (Tehran: Enteshar Corp, 2013). [In Persian]
- Mohseni, Saeed, Mistake in the Identity of the Contracting Party (With a Comparative Study in Iranian and French Law), 1st ed., (Tehran: Imam Sadiq University Press, 2011). [In Persian]
Articles
- Sarmadi, Abbas & Haghighat, Saba, “Legal Analysis of Risk in the Contracts System with an Approach to Imam Khomeini's View)”, Matin Research Journal, 17th Year, No. 67, (2015). [In Persian]
- Shiri, Mehrzad; Bagheri, Ahmad & Khorsandian, Mohammad Ali, “Conflict in Contract and the Efficiency of Jurisprudential Rules in its Interpretation”, Studies in Islamic Jurisprudence and Law, 7th Year, No. 12, (2015). [In Persian]
In Arabic
- Al-Ifriqi Al-Masri (Ibn Manzur) & Abu al-Fadl Jamal al-Din Muhammad ibn Mukarram, Lisan Al-arab, Vol. 5, (Qom: Adab al-Hawzah, 1984). [In Arabic]
- Al-Karaki (Mohaghegh Thani), Sheikh Nur al-Din Ali bin Al-Husayn, Jami' al-Maqasid fi Sharh al-Qawa'id, Vol. 4, 2nd ed., (Qom: Aal al-Bayt Institute, 1993). [In Arabic]
- Al-Shartouni Al-Lubnani, Saeed Khoury, Aqrab al-Mawarid fi Fusah al-Arabiyyah wa al-Shawarid, Vol. 4 (Qom: Publications of Grand Ayatollah Mar'ashi Najafi Library, 1982). [In Arabic]
- Ameli (Shahid Thani), Zayn al-Din bin Ali bin Ahmad, Masalik Al-afham Ila Tanqih Shara'i' al-Islam, Vol. 3 (Qom: Mu'assasat al-Ma'arif al-Islamiyyah, 1992). [In Arabic]
- Ansari (Sheikh Ansari), Morteza bin Mohammad Amin, Kitab al-Makasib, Vol. 4, 8th ed., (Qom: Majma' al-Fikr al-Islami, 2007). [In Arabic]
- Ansari (Sheikh Ansari), Morteza bin Mohammad Amin, Kitab al-Makasib, Vol. 2, 1st ed., (Qom: Matba'ah al-Khayyam, 1990). [In Arabic]
- Araghi, Aqa Ziya al-Din, Sharh Tabsirat al-Muta'allimin, Researched by Mohammad Hassoun, Vol. 5 (Qom: Islamic Publishing Institute, 1993). [In Arabic]
- Bahrani (Mohaghegh Bahrani), Yousef bin Ahmad, Al-Hada'iq al-Nadirah, Vol. 19 (Qom: Islamic Publishing Institute, N.d.). [In Arabic]
- Esfahani (Sheikh Kompani), Mohammad Hossein, Hashiyah Kitab al-Makasib, Vol. 4, researched by Abbas Mohammad Al Siba', (Qom: Dar al-Mustafa li-Ihya al-Turath, 1998). [In Arabic]
- Hilli (Allamah Hilli), Hasan bin Yousef bin Motahhar, Tadhkirat Al-fuqaha, Vol. 10 (Qom: Aal al-Bayt Institute for the Revival of Heritage, 1993). [In Arabic]
- Hosseini Ameli, Seyed Mohammad Javad, Miftah Al-karamah fi Sharh Qawa'id al-Allamah, Vol. 13 (Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated with the Society of Seminary Teachers, 1998). [In Arabic]
- Kashif al-Ghita, Muhammad Husayn, Tahrir al-Majallah, Vol. 1 (Najaf: Al-Maktabah Al-Murtadawiyyah, 1939). [In Arabic]
- Maghrebi Al-Fayyumi, Ahmad bin Mohammad bin Ali, Al-Misbah al-Munir, 3rd ed., (Beirut: Sharikat Abna' Sharif Al-Ansari, 2007). [In Arabic]
- Makki (Shahid Awwal), Muhammad bin Muhammad, Al-Durus al-Shar'iyyah fi Fiqh al-Imamiyyah, Vol. 3, 2nd ed., (Qom: Islamic Publishing Institute, 1996). [In Arabic]
- Mamaqani (Mohaghegh Thani), Abdullah, Manahij al-Muttaqin fi Fiqh A'immat al-Haqq wa al-Yaqin (Najaf: Aal al-Bayt Institute for the Revival of Heritage, 1965). [In Arabic]
- Mousavi Khoei, Abolqasem, Misbah al-Fiqahah fi al-Mu'amalat, Vol. 6 (Beirut: Dar al-Hadi, 1991). [In Arabic]
- Najafi Iravani, Mirza Ali, Hashiyah al-Makasib, Vol. 2 (Tehran: Kiya, 2005). [In Arabic]
- Najafi, Muhammad Hasan, Jawahir al-Kalam fi Sharh Shara'i' al-Islam, Vol. 23 (Tehran: Dar al-Kutub al-Islamiyyah, 1979). [In Arabic]
- Naraqi, Mulla Muhammad bin Ahmad, Mashariq al-Ahkam, 2nd ed., (Qom: Naraqiyin Congress, 2001). [In Arabic]
- Sabzevari (Mohaghegh Sabzevari), Mohammad Bagher bin Mohammad Momen, Kifayat al-Ahkam, Vol. 1 (Isfahan: Sadr Mahdavi School, N.d.). [In Arabic]
- Shahidi Tabrizi, Mir Fattah, Hidayat al-Talib ila Asrar al-Makasib, Vol. 3 (Qom: Dar al-Kitab, N.d.). [In Arabic]
- Tabatabaei Yazdi, Seyed Mohammad Kazem, Hashiyah al-Makasib, 4th ed., Vol. 2 (Qom: Ismaeilian, 1991). [In Arabic]
- Tusi, Abu Jafar Muhammad bin Hassan, Al-Mabsut fi Fiqh al-Imamiyyah, Vol. 2, 3rd ed., (Tehran: Al-Maktabah Al-Murtadawiyyah li-Ihya al-Athar al-Ja'fariyyah, 1967). [In Arabic]
- Zakariya, Ahmad bin Faris, Mu'jam Maqayis al-Lughah, Vol. 4 (Qom: Publication Center: Islamic Information Office, 1983). [In Arabic]