Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Private Law, Damghan Branch, Islamic Azad University, , Damghan, Damghan, Iran

2 PhD in Private Law, Semnan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Semnan, Semnan, Iran

3 Master of Laws, Damghan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Damghan, , Damghan, Iran

Abstract

The supervisory board subject to Article 6 of the Real Estate Registration Law, as the authority for dealing with all disputes and registration errors, lacks the guarantees of a fair hearing, and the implementation of the current method is an insistence on inadequacies that do not contribute to the judicial situation of the country and the policy of decriminalization. . It is possible to take a step towards speeding up and facilitating the proceedings with minor reforms such as the expansion of delegation of authority, the formation of numerous and specialized branches, the revision of executive regulations and registration directives, but inadequacies such as the weakness of this quasi-judicial authority's entry into the nature Registration disputes and referral to judicial authorities (in cases where there is a threat of violation of acquired rights of individuals) are still standing. The first question of the article is why the supervisory board should deal with the errors and discrepancies in the registration. And in this regard, what are the justifications for the need for quasi-judicial authorities to enter into the nature of disputes? Secondly, assuming that the supervisory board (with its current status) does not have the ability to deal substantively with errors and registration disputes, what reforms and tools should be provided to the boards for the development of alternative dispute resolution methods?
 

Keywords

Aghaei Jantmekan, Hossein, Rights of fair and fair proceedings (Judicial), (Tehran: Jangal Publications, 2016) (In Persian).
Azizi, Ebrahim and others, "The effect of the judge selection method on the independence of the judge in the law of the United States with a view to the law of Iran", Comparative Law Research, No. 1 (2012) (In Persian).
Bahrami, Dariush, Real Estate Registration Laws in Iran, second edition, (Tehran: Mizan Legal Foundation, 2013) (In Persian).
Dehghani, Hossein, "Managing the Time to Accelerate Litigation", Ta'ala Law Journal, No. 12 (2010) (In Persian).
Domichel, Andre; Pierre, Lalumier, Public Law, translated by Abolfazl Qazi, Tehran, (Dadgostar Publishing House, Tehran: 1376) (In Persian).
Eftekhar Jahormi, Gooders, the right of the accused to benefit from a lawyer in the criminal procedure law, encyclopedia of criminal sciences, book 2, (Tehran: Mezan Publishing, 2012) (In Persian).
Emami, Mohammad; Mousavi, Seyyed Nasrullah, "Theoretical foundations of quasi-judicial authorities and their position in Iranian law", Journal of Social and Human Sciences of Shiraz University, serial 41, number 2, (2013) (In Persian).
Fathi, Mohammad Javad, Dehghani, Ali, "Investigator's independence in conducting preliminary investigations and its effect on achieving a fair trial", Journal of Jurisprudence and Law (2008).
Ghomami, Majid; Mohseni, Hassan, "Principles guaranteeing democratic performance in proceedings and principles related to the characteristics of civil proceedings", Law Journal of Tehran University Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, No. 74 (2015) (In Persian).
Ghomami, Majid, Mohseni, Hassan; Transnational Civil Procedure Rules (Tehran, Publishing Co., Ltd., 1390) (In Persian).
Hadavand, Mahdi, Aghaei Touq, Moslem, Special Administrative Courts in the Light of Principles and Fair Procedures (Iranian Law and Comparative Study), (Tehran: Khorsandi Publications, 2014) (In Persian).
Haghighat, Ali, Real Estate Registration in Iran, 2nd edition (Tehran: Ganj Danesh Library Publications, 2017) (In Persian).
Judiciary Research Institute, strategies to promote fair proceedings in specialized non-judicial authorities, (Tehran: Judiciary Press and Publishing Center, 2017) (In Persian).
Mafi, Homayun; Ghamiloyi, Mohammad, "The concept and guarantee of the implementation of "principles of procedure" in civil procedure", Journal of Legal Encyclopedias, period 2, number 3 (2018) (In Persian).
Mohseni, Hassan, "Technology of conducting civil proceedings, organizing proceedings in the form of procedural principles", Law Quarterly, Journal of Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran, Volume 40, Number 4 (2009) (In Persian).
Naji Zawareh, Morteza, "Impartiality in criminal proceedings", Judiciary Legal Journal, No. 56-57 (2007) (In Persian).
Niazpour, Amirhossein, "The right of the accused to remove a lawyer in the criminal process; A Manifestation of Citizen Rights", Judiciary Law Journal, No. 58, (2016) (In Persian)
Nikoyi, Samia, "Requirements of publicness of criminal proceedings in the light of fair proceedings", Legal Journal of Justice, No. 56-57 (2015) (In Persian).
Paknahad, Amir, Pathology of death penalty in Iranian law, Encyclopaedia of Criminal Sciences, second edition, (Tehran: Mezan Publishing, 2012) (In Persian).
Razavifard, Behzad; Gurbanzadeh, Hossein, "The right to public proceedings as one of the defense rights of the accused in international criminal courts", Journal of Comparative Law of Tehran University, Volume 7, Number 1, (2015) (In Persian).
Shams, Abdullah, Advanced Course of Civil Procedure, Volume 1, 35th Edition, (Tehran: Darak Publications, 2014) (In Persian).
Saber, Mahmoud; Tabatabai Hessari, Nasreen, "Legal and Economic Effects of Real Estate Registration System", Law Quarterly Journal of Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, Volume 41, Number 2 (Summer 2019) (In Persian).
Saber, Mahmoud; Nazerian, Hossein, "Reasonable deadline for proceedings in the International Criminal Court and the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights", Tarbiat Modares University Comparative Law Research Journal, Volume 18, Number 4 (2013) (In Persian).
Saqri, Mohammad, "The validity of apparent authenticity in civil law (a discussion on Iranian and French law)", Law and Politics Research Quarterly, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, Allameh Tabatabai University, 8th year, number 18 (2015) (In Persian).
Tabatabai Hessari, Nasreen, Basics and works of real estate registration system, (Tehran: Publishing Company, 1389) (In Persian).
Tabatabai Hessari, Nasreen; Kazemi, Mahmoud, "The position of third party protection in real estate registration systems", Journal of Comparative Law Studies, University of Tehran, Volume 4, Number 1 (2012) (In Persian).
Tabatabai Hessari, Nasreen, "Abstract Description of Real Estate Registration System Based on Public Trust Theory", Tehran University Comparative Law Studies Journal, Volume 5, Number 2 (2014) (In Persian).
Tabatabai Motamani, Manouchehr, Administrative Law of Iran, 5th edition (Tehran: Mehr Publications, 2014) (In Persian).
Tajarlo, Reza et al., "The role and function of the commission for dealing with disputes arising from national lands from the perspective of the principles of fair proceedings", Public Law Research Quarterly of Tarbiat Modares University, No. 49 (2014) (In Persian).
Tank, Andre, translated by: Safaei, Seyed Hossein, Hosseini, Seyed Ehsan, Basics and principles of civil responsibility from the perspective of comparative law, (Tehran: Sahami Publishing Co., Ltd., 2018) (In Persian).
Tavzonizadeh, Abbas, "Reflection on the impact of the theory of governance practices and tenure practices on the legal regime governing government organizations and plans to reform the structure of Iran's administrative system", Majles and Strategy Magazine, No. 51, (2015) (In Persian).
 
Vahed, Shaghayegh; Maboudi Neishabouri, Reza, "The independence and impartiality of the arbitrator; Synonymy or distinction? (Comparative study in international commercial arbitration)", Comparative Law Studies, Volume 6, Number 1 (2014) (In Persian).
Yavari, Asadollah, "Introduction to the concept of law regulation", Tehran University Comparative Law Assembly, Volume 5, Number 2, (2013) (In Persian).
Zareh, Abbas; Ahmadi, Anwar, "Fundamentals and effects of the presence principle of criminal proceedings", Journal of Criminal Law Research, Volume 5, Number 2 (2013)  (In Persian).
 
ب) انگلیسی
ALI / UNIDROIT Principles of Transnational Civil Procedure, Copyright © 2006 The American Law Institute and UNIDROIT
BEHIN (j.), »Les societies civiles professionnelles notariales«, 4e rapport au 67e congress des Notaires, in Theorie et Pratique des societs civiles, Paris: Librairies techniques, 1970
Draft Rules of Transnational Civil Procedure
Ferrand, Frederique, Le principe contradictoire et l'expertise en droit compare european, in: revue international de droit compare, Vol. 52 N°2 (Avril-juin 2000), P. 345-369.
Manzanares Bastida, Bruno. (2007). The Independence and Impartiality of Arbitraitor in International Commercial Arbitration. No. 1. Vol. 6.