Document Type : Research Paper
Author
Associate Professor, Department of Law and Social Jurisprudence, Research Institute of Islamic Sciences, Research Institute of Hawzah and University, Qom, Iran,
Abstract
One of the most controversial issues about which there are different ideas is the issue of cheating the law and its effects in both domestic law and private International law. In Iranian law, there is no a legal article that explicitly states the verdict of cheating, so the judge in the face of cheating, based on Principle One Hundred and Sixty Seven of the Constitution, must refer to valid sources or jurisprudential Fatwas (Sharia and Islamic jurisprudence) and rule. One issue that can be documented to some extent is the issue of trickery. In this article, after mentioning cheating in customary law and explaining trickery in Islamic jurisprudence, the author compares these two concepts thematically and jurisprudentially, and in an attempt to infer the verdict of cheating from the verdict of trickery, concludes that according to the issue of trickery, it is impossible to consider one verdict for cheating, but depending on the different types of cheating, various verdicts will be ruled on cheating.
Keywords
Ablaghdar, Sedigheh, An Investigation into the Theory of Fraud and Sharia Tricks in Jurisprudence and Law (Tehran: Omid Majd Publication, 2007). (in Persian)
Akasheh, Mohammad Abd al-Al, The Conflict of Rules (Beirut: Manshourat al-Halabi al-Hoghoughiah, 2004). (in Persian)
Almasi, Nejad Ali, The Conflict of Rules (Tehran: Center for Academic Publishing, 1989). (in Persian)
Alvani, Nashvah, Al-Hial al-Sharia bein al-Hazar va al-Ebahah (Hejaz: Dar Eghra, 2002). (in Persian)
Ameri, Javad, Private International Law (Tehran: Agah Publication, 1983). (in Persian)
Amid Zanjani, Abas Ali, The Rules of Jurisprudence, The Part of Private Law, vol.1 (Tehran: Samt, 2007). (in Persian)
Ardabili Mohaghegh (Moghadas), Ahmad ibn Mohammad, Majma al-Faedah va al-Borhan fi Sharh Ershad al-Azhan, vol.6 (Qom: Islamic Publishing Office Affiliated with the Seminary Teachers' Community, 1993). (in Persian)
Arfania, Behshid, Private International Law, vol.2 (Tehran: Behtab Publication, 1997). (in Persian)
Behbahani, Vahid, Al-Rasael al-Fiqhiah (Qom: Alameh Mojadad Vahid Behbahani's Institute, 1998). (in Persian)
Beyarmaier, Fanson Houzieh, Al-Ghanoun al-Dovali al-Khas, Translated by Ali Mahmoud Moghaled (Beirut: Majd, Moaseseh al-Jameiah Lelderasat va al-Nashr va al-Tozi, 2008). (in Persian)
Boheiri, Al-Hial, al-Mahzour Menha va al-Mashrou (Cairo: Al-Mesr Publication, 1946). (in Persian)
Boheiri, Mohammad Abdolvahab, Sharia Tricks Incompatible with the Philosophy of Jurisprudence, Translated by Hussein Saberi (Mashhad: Astan Ghods Razavi, 1997). (in Persian)
Bostani, Saeid Yousef, Al-Ghanoun al-Dovali al-Khas (Beirut: Manshourat al-Halabi al-Hoghoughiah, 2004). (in Persian)
Buhuti, Mansour ibn Younes, Kashaf al-Ghena, vol.3 (Beirut: Dar al-Fekr, 1982). (in Persian)
Civil Law. (in Persian)
Constitution. (in Persian)
Davoudi, Ali, Al-Ghanoun al-Dovali al-Khas, The Conflict of Rules (Oman: Dar al-Seghafah Lelnashr va al-Tozi, 2011). (in Persian)
Dehkhoda, Ali Akbar, Dictionary (Tehran: University of Tehran Publication, 1951). (in Persian)
Ekhvanfard, Masoud; Keikha Farzaneh, Mohammad Amin; Badi Sanaye, Amin, "A Comparison between the Law and Sharia Tricks in Private Law in the Case of Fraud", Research Journal of Islamic Law, vol.14, no.2, 2013, pp.181-212. (in Persian)
Esmaeil ibn Hamal, Al-Sahah Taj al-Loghah (Beirut: Dar al-Elm Lelmalaein, 1987). (in Persian)
Fayazi, Seyed Mohammad Reza, The Jurisprudential Ways of Getting Rid of Opposition to Sharia Rulings (Qom: Publication of the Jurisprudential Center of Athar Imams, 2014). (in Persian)
Ghadir, Mohsen & Kazemi Foroushani, Hussein, "Theoretical Fundamentals of the Cheating of the Law and Its Impacts on Imamiah Jurisprudence and Iranian Private International Law", Journal of Comparative Research of Islamic and Western Law, vol.8, no.2 (2021), pp.224-226. (in Persian)
Ghasemi, Rasoul, Deception and Cheating of the Law (in the Iranian Law and Jurisprudence) (Tehran: Jungle and Javdaneh Publication, 2012). (in Persian)
Hadavi, Hassan, Tanazo al-Ghavanin va Ahkamoh fi al-Ghanoun al-Dovali al-Khas al-Kuwaiti (Kuwait: Matbouat Jameah al-Kuwait, 1974). (in Persian)
Heli, Mohaghegh, Sharaye al-Islam, vol.3 (Najaf: Al-Adab Publication, 1969). (in Persian)
Ibn Ghayem, Ibn Abdollah, Elam al-Moghe'in, vol.3 (Beirut: Dar al-Jabal, 1973). (in Persian)
Jafari Langeroudi, Mohammad Jafar, Vasit in Terminology of Law (Tehran: Ganj Danesh Library, First Print, 2009). (in Persian)
Kashani, Seyed Mahmoud, The Theory of Cheating the Law (Tehran: National University of Iran, 1975). (in Persian)
Kazemi Foroushani, Hussein & Ghadir, Mohsen, "The Theoretical Requirements of Cheating the Law from the Perspective of Iranian Law", Journal of Private and Criminal Law Research, no.45 (2020), pp.69-71. (in Persian)
Khomeini, Rouhollah, Al-Makaseb al-Moharamah (Tehran: Imam Khomeini Editing and Publishing Institute, 1998). (in Persian)
Khomeini, Rouhollah, Haj Rituals, Compatible with Imam Khomeini's Fatwa and the Margins of Other Maraja (Tehran: Mashar Publication, 1996). (in Persian)
Khomeini, Rouhollah, Tozih al-Masael (Tehran: Imam Khomeini Editing and Publishing Institute, 1998). (in Persian)
Makarem Shirazi, Naser, Al-Ghavaed al-Fiqhiah, vol.1 (Qom: School of Imam Amir al-Momenin, 2014). (in Persian)
Makarem Shirazi, Naser, An Investigation into the Ways of Getting Rid of Usury (Qom: School of Imam Amir al-Momenin, 2006). (in Persian)
Makarem Shirazi, Naser, Sharia Tricks and Correct Solutions, Gathered by Abolghasem Aliannejadi (Qom: Imam Ali ibn abi Taleb Publication, Forth Print, 2010). (in Persian)
Mamdouh, Abdolkarim, Al-Ghanoun al-Dovali al-Khas (Baghdad: Dar al-Horiah Lelteba'ah va al-Nashr, 1973). (in Persian)
Mamdouh, Abdolkarim, Al-Ghanoun al-Dovali al-Khas (Oman: Dar al-Seghafah Lelnashr va al-Tozi, 2005). (in Persian)
Motahari, Morteza, Usury, Bank and Insurance (Tehran: Sadra Publication, 1985). (in Persian)
Motavali, Seyed Mohammad, Personal Status of Foreigners in Iran (n.p.: Mechanism Publication, 1999). (in Persian)
Najafi, Mohammad Hassan, Javaher al-Kalam, vol.32 (Beirut: Dar al-Kotob al-Eslamiah, Second Print, 1983). (in Persian)
Nasiri, Mohammad, Private International Law (Tehran: Agah Publication, 1993). (in Persian)
Nazif, Mojtaba, Private International Law, vol.2 (Tehran: Dadgostar Publication, 2010). (in Persian)
Sadri Arhami, Mohammad, Sharia Tricks in the Jurisprudence and Law (Tehran: Chatr Danesh Publication, 2015). (in Persian)
Salamah, Ahmad Abdolkarim, Al-Ghanoun al-Dovali al-Khas (Al-Ain (United Arab Emirates): Jameiah al-Arabia al-Motahedah, 2002). (in Persian)
Saljoughi, Mahmoud, Private International Law, vol.2 (Tehran: Mizan Publication, 2002). (in Persian)
Shahid Sani, Zeinodin, Masalek al-Afham ela Tanghih Sharaye al-Islam, vol.1 (Qom: Al-Ma'aref al-Eslamiah Institute, 1992). (in Persian)
Shariat Bagheri, Mohammad Javad, Private International Law (Tehran: Mizan Publication, 2016). (in Persian)
Shatebi, Ebrahim ibn Mousa, Al-Movafeghat, vol.1 (Beirut: Dar Ibn Afan, 1996). (in Persian)
Sheikholeslami, Seyed Mohsen, Private International Law (Tehran: Ganje Danesh Library, 2005). (in Persian)
Shirazi, Seyed Mohammad, Islal al-Taleb ela al-Makaseb, vol.1 (Tehran: Manshourat al-Alami, n.d.). (in Persian)
Sohrabi, Mohammad, Private International Law (Tehran: Ganj Danesh Library, 2006). (in Persian)
Tousi, Mohammad ibn al-Hassan, Al-Khalaf, vol.4 (Qom: Al-Nashr al-Eslami, 1994). (in Persian)
Tousi, Mohammad ibn al-Hassan, Mabsout, vols.3, 5 (Tehran: Al-Maktabah al-Mortazaviah, n.d.). (in Persian)
)