Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Ph.D. Candidate in International Oil and Gas Contract Management, Allameh Tabataba'i University

2 Associate Prof., Private Law AllamehTabataba'i University, Faculty of Law and Political Science

3 Assistant Prof., University of Tehran, Faculty of Law

Abstract

Med-Arb is one of the hybrid and integrated dispute settlement mechanisms which embodies flexibility, non-judicial and negotiate-oriented benefits of "mediation" and finality advantage of "arbitration" simultaneously and in a single process. In this article, med-arb nature is identified through a comprehensive comparative legal study including major legal systems and procedural rules of leading dispute settlement institutions. Opportunities and challenges of adopting med-arb in terms of legal, economic and managerial perspectives is analyzed. Although this method provides parties with a huge flexibility, control over the process and great efficiency (in relation to other dispute settlement mechanisms), some serious challenges regarding enforcement of awards in international contracts exist. In light of International Commercial Arbitration Act of Iran and Civil Procedure Code (regarding domestic arbitration rules), in case that parties reach agreement in the first phase (mediation), it is not possible that mediator only serve as arbitrator so that be powered to change the mediation agreement into an arbitral award. However, if parties fail to reach agreement in the first phase and arbitration initiates accordingly, their settlement in this stage can be regarded as consent award and be subject to benefits of enforcement of international arbitration awards.

Keywords

-  Andersen K Steven, 2010, “ICDROffersConcurrent Mediation/ Arbitration Clause”, AAA/ICDR Handbook on International Arbitration and ADR - 2nd Edition", available at:
-  Barkett, John, 2010, “Avoiding The Cost of International Commercial Arbitration: is Mediation the Solution?” Contemporary Issues in International Arbitration and Mediation, Fordham Law school papers 2010, MArtnus nijhoff publishers.
-  Brian A. Pappas,2015, “ Med-ArbandtheLegalizationof Alternative DisputeResolution” , 20 HarvardNegotiationLawReview. NegotLReview 157, 159
-  Born B Gary, Shenkman, Ethan,2014, “ConfidentialityandTransparencyin CommercialandInvestor-StateArbitration”, The Future of Investment Arbitration, Oxford university press.
-  Chau, Eunice, 2018, “a Contribution to the Conversation on Mixing the Modes of Mediation and Arbitration: of Definitional Consistency and Process Structure Transnational Dispute Management”, Research Collection School of law. available: http://ink.library.smu.edu.sg_research /2771
-  Ellen E. Deason,2013, “CombinationsofMediationandArbitrationwiththe Same Neutral: A Framework for Judicial Review”, 5 Y.B. Arb.& Mediation 219.
-  Kryvoi Yaraslau, Davydenko Dmitry, 2005, “ConsentAwardsinInternational Arbitration: fromSettlementto Enforcement”, BrooklynJournalofInternationallaw, Vol 40, issue 3.
-  Limbury, Allan, 2010, “HybridDisputeResolutionProcesses: GettingtheBestWhileAvoidingtheWorstofBothWorlds?” Availableat: https:// www.imimediation.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/hybrid-processes-2010-article-by-alan-limbury.pdf, last visited: January 13, 2019.
 
-  Lee, Jae Sung, “WorkofUNCITRALintheFieldofMediationandConciliation–Enforceabilityof Settlement Agreements”, availableat: www.sloarbitration.eu/ .../UNCITRAL.../ Work%20of%20UNCITRAL%20in%20the%2...
-  Luis M. Martinez and Thomas Ventrone, 2010, “TheInternational CenterforDisputeResolutionMediationPractice”, Contemporaryissuesininternationalarbitrationandmediation, 2010, Fordham Law School,pp 484-496.
-   Merril,G Peter, 2018, “binding mediation” AmericanBar AssociationSectionofDisputeResolution, available at: https:// www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/administrative/dispute_resolution/newsletter/may2018/merrill-binding-mediation.pdf, last visited: January 8, 2019.
-  Pappas, Brian A, 2015, “Med-ArbandTheLegalizationofAlternative Dispute Resolution”,
http://www.hnlr.org/wp-content/uploads/HNR104_crop.pdf, last visited: 3/11/2018.
-  Thomas W. Walde,2004, “Pro-active Mediation of International Business and Investment Disputes involving Long-term Contracts: from Zero-Sum Litigation to Efficient Dispute Management, UNPAD Journal of International Law, Vol. 3 No 1.
-  Walde, Thomas, 2006, “efficient management of transnational disputes: mutual gain by mediation or joint loss in litigation, Arbitration International, vol. 22, No. 2