Document Type : Research Paper
Authors
1 Associated Professor, Department of Private and Economic Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Allameh Tabatabai University, Tehran, Iran
2 Ph.D. in Management of International Oil and gas Contracts, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Allameh Tabatabai University, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
For decades, companies involved in the petroleum industry are committed to complying with International Petroleum Industry Practices (IPIP) or similar terms in performing most of their obligations and operations. This paper examines the consequences of a breach of IPIP in light of reviewing dispute resolution methods in different regimes governing the upstream sector. Reviewing disputes and lawsuits related to the breach of IPIP suggests the different enforcement methods under the various regimes of operation in the upstream sector. With regard to the Iranian petroleum industry, using the results of this comparative study, it was shown that due to the contractual regime used in the relations between the National Iranian Oil Company (NIOC) and International Oil Companies (IOCs) involved in the development of the Iranian upstream sector, any dispute over IPIP as part of contractual terms will cause new risks by triggering the arbitration mechanism. It was also suggested that the preparation of IPIP in the form of precise documents and their periodical update by relevant authorities, including the Ministry of Petroleum, may reduce disputes between the contracting parties (NIOC and IOCs) and determine the latter’s scope of authorities related to selection and application of IPIP.
Keywords
Main Subjects
Ahmadi Vastani, Abdolhjani, »A brief description of Algerian Declarations«, International Law Review, Volume 1, Issue 1, (1985).
Beigzadeh, Safar, (Editor), Iran-U.S. Claims Tribunal Reports- Volume VI, President Office, Deputy for Legal Affairs, Office of Codification, revision and publication of laws and regulations, (2014).
Derakhshan, Masoud, »Oil Contracts from MER and IOR/EOR Standpoint: The Resilient Economy Approach«, Islamic Economics Studies Bi-quarterly Journal, Volume 6, Issue 2, (2014).
Ebrahimi, Seyyed Nasrollah and Janfada , Amir, »Legal and Contractual Status of Income Taxation in Upstream Contracts of Oil and Gas Industry with Emphasis on Iranian Petroleum Projects«, Quarterly Energy Economics Review, Volume16, Number 67, (2021).
El-Kosheri, A. S. & Riad, T., »The Law Governing New Generation of Petroleum Agreements: Changes in the Arbitration Process«, translated by Mohebi, Mohsen, International Law Review, Volume 20, Issue 29, (2003).
Green Book (White Book), History and text of contracts related to Iranian oil Industry (Petroleum Law, National Iranian Oil Company Articles of Association), (Tehran: National Iranian Oil Company, 1965).
Kashani, Javad and Damanpak, Jafar »Nature of International Petroleum Industry Practices and Their Impacts on Law Governing Upstream Contracts«, Energy Law Studies, Volume 6, Issue 2, (2021).
Katoozian, Naser, Civil code in legal order, (Tehran: Mizan Law foundation, 2014).
Katoozian, Naser, General Rules of Contracts - Volume 3 of Contract Effects, (Tehran: Enteshar Co, 2016).
Mohebi, Mohsen, »Legal nature of the Iran-United States Claims Tribunal from the perspective of international law«, International Law Review, Volume 13, Issue 18-19, (1995).
Mousavi Fazlollah and Einy, Mojtaba, »The New Approach in Legal Analysis of Environmental Clauses in Petroleum Contracts«, Energy Law Studies, Volume 5, Issue 1, (2019).
Saeedi, Alimohammad, »3 papers on Iranian petroleum Industry«, Majlis & Pajouhesh, The Journal of Majlis Research Centre, Volume 9, Number 34, Special Issue: Oil and the National Interest, (2002).
Shiravi, Abdolhossein, Oil and Gas Law, (4th Edition), (Tehran: Mizan Law foundation, 2018).
Shiravi, Abdolhossein and Ebrahimi, Seyed Nasrollah, »Exploration and development of Iran's oilfields through buyback«, translated by Asgharian, Mojtaba, International Law Review, Volume 26, Issue 41, (2010).
Shiravi, Abdolhossein and Falahati, Mahin, »Contractual Framework of Decommissioning of Petroleum Installations and Facilities«, Journal of Private Law, Volume 14, Issue 1, (2017).
Tajarloo, Reza and Abdi, Sadegh, »Comparative Study of the Dispute Resolution Boards of the Ministry of Oil and International FIDIC Contracts«, Energy Law Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2, (2019).
Zahraie, Morteza, »Remedies For the Enforcement of the International Arbitral Awards«, International Law Review, Volume 21, Issue 31, (2004).
Zeinodin Seyyed Mostafa and Shahmoradi, Esmat, »A comparative study of environmental provisions in international oil contracts«, Energy Law Studies, Volume 1, Issue 2, (2016).
ب) انگلیسی
Bourgeois, Loyd L. (2004), “Private Actions Seeking Remediation or Restoration' Damages: Who Ensures the Clean-up Actually Occurs?ˮ, Tulane Environmental Law Journal, Vol. 17.
Conine, Gary B. (2001), “The Prudent Operator Standard: Applications beyond the Oil and Gas Lease, Natural Resources Journal, Volume 41.
Feriancek, Jeanine. (1996) “Liability for Negligenceˮ, Natural Resource And Environment, Vol. 11, No. 1.
Galanter, Marc. (1983) “Reading the landscape of disputes: What we know and don’t know (and think we know) about our allegedly contentious and litigious societyˮ, UCLA Law Review, Vol. 31.
García, Julian C. (2012) “Best Industry Practices and Environmental Regulation for Offshore Petroleum Operations - A Contribution to the Study of the Lex Petroleaˮ. TPLI Series on Transnational Petroleum Law, Vol. 1, N° 2.
Konschnik, Kate. (2018), “Private Environmental Governance In Oil And Gas: Unlocking The Complex Universe of Leading Management Practicesˮ, Journal of Land Use, Vol. 33 No. 2.
Krueger, Robert B. (1978), “The Management of Federal Petroleum Resources in The United Statesˮ, International and Comparative Law Quarterly, Vol. 27.
Kuntz, Eugene O.. A Treatise on the Law of Oil and Gas: Including Forms, Statutes, Regulations, Volume 4, (Anderson Publishing Company, 1972).
Lowe, John S. “Some Recurring Issues in Operating Agreements and What AAPL’s Drafting Committee Might Do About Themˮ, 60 Rocky Mt. Min. L. Inst. (2014).
Martin, T., “Decommissioning of International Petroleum Facilities, Evolving Standards and Key Issuesˮ, Oil, Gas & Energy Law Journal Vol. 1. Also at International Energy Law Course, RMMLF Mineral Law Series. Also at OGEL 5 (2003).
Meyers, Charles J. (1963), “Compulsory Joinder of Parties in Implied Covenant Litigationˮ, Stanford Law Review, Vol. 16, pp. 43-74.
Miller, David W. (1963), “The Historical Development of the Oil and Gas Laws of the United Statesˮ, California Law Review, Vol. 51, No. 3.
Moore, Loretta W. and Pierce, David E. (1997), “A Structural Model for Arbitrating, Disputes Under the Oil and Gas Leaseˮ, Natural Resources Journal, Vol. 37.
Pierce, David E. (1987), “Rethinking the Oil and Gas Leaseˮ, Tulsa Law Journal, Vol. 22, No. 4.
Pendery, Bruce M. (2010), “BLM's Retained Rights: How Requiring Environmental Protection Fulfills Oil And Gas Lease Obligationsˮ, Environmental Law, Vol.40.
Ramazani, Rouhollah K. (1962), “Choice-of-Law Problems and International Oil Contracts: A Case Studyˮ, The International and Comparative Law Quarterly, Vol. 11, No. 2.
Strong, Christopher B. (eds.). The Oil and Gas Law Review. 4th Edition. (London: Law Business Research Ltd, 2016).
Sullivan, Robert Edwin. Handbook of Oil and Gas Law. 2nd Edition. (Prentice-Hall, 1955).
Decisions
Abraxas Petroleum Corp. v. Hornburg, (2000), Texas Courts of Appeals, No. 08-98-00286-CV, 20 S.W.3d 741.
American Petroleum Institute v. United States Environmental Protection Agency, (2000), United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, Nos. 94-1683, 94-1684, 94-1686, 98-1494, 98-1506, 98-1507, 98-1514, 342 U.S. App. D.C. 159, 216 F.3d 50.
Amoco Production Co. v. Alexander, (1981), Supreme Court of Texas, No. B-9131, 622 S.W.2d 563.
Butcher v. Okmar Oil Co., (1977), Court of Appeal of the State of California, Civ. No. 49493, 65 Cal. App. 3d 972.
Cannon v. Sun-Key Oil Co., (2003), Texas Courts of Appeals, No. 11-02-00286-CV, 117 S.W.3d 416.
Castle Texas Production Limited Partnership, et al, v. The Long Trusts, (2003), Texas Courts of Appeals , No. 12-01-00192-CV, 134 S.W.3d.
Cedar Creek Oil & Gas Co. v. Fidelity Gas Co., (1957), United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, No. 15293, 249 F.2d 277.
Compton v. Fisher-McCall, Inc., (1941), Michigan Supreme Court, Docket No. 51, Calendar No. 41,489. 298 Mich. 648.
Energen Resources MAQ, Inc. v. Dalbosco, (2000), Texas Courts of Appeals, No. 01-99-00553-CV, 23 S.W.3d 551.
Environment Protection Authority v. Great Southern Energy, (1999), NSWLEC 19. At: https://www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au/decision/549f775a3004262463a87d86
Exxon Mobil Corp. v. Commissioner, (2000), United States Tax Court, Docket Nos. 18618-89, 18432-90, 114 T.C. 293.
Exxon Mobil Corp. v. United States Environmental Protection Agency, (2000), United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, No. 99-70945, 217 F.3d 1246.
Exxon Mobil Corp. & Affiliated Companies v. Commissioner, (2007), United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, No. 06-60276, 484 F.3d 731.
Exxon Mobil Corp. & Affiliated Cos. v. Commissioner, (2012), United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, Docket Nos. 11-2814, 11-2817, 689 F.3d 191.
In re Motor Fuel Temperature Sales Practices Litigation, (2008), United States District Court for the District of Kansas, MDL No. 1840; No. 07-MD-1840-KHV, 534 F. Supp. 2d 1214.
In re Oil Spill by the Oil Rig Deepwater Horizon, (2015), United States District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana, No. MDL 2179, 77 F. Supp. 3d 500.
IP Petroleum Co. v. Wevanco Energy, L.L.C., Texas Courts of Appeals, No. 01-02-00106-CV, 116 S.W.3d 888.
Iranian Court Decision on Arbitral Award in Dispute Between Sapphire International Petroleums Ltd. and the National Iranian Oil Company. (1970). International Legal Materials, 9(6), p.1118-1124.
Joint Venture Yashlar and Bridas S.A.P.I.C. v. Turkmenistan, ICC Case No. 9151/FMS/KGA, Interim Award of 8 June 1999. At:
Lamb County Electric Cooperative, Inc. v. Public Utility Commission, (2008), Texas Courts of Appeals, No. 03-04-00593-CV 269, S.W.3d 260.
Lightcap v. Mobil Oil Corp., (1977), Kansas Supreme Court, No. 47,991, 221 Kan. 448, 562 P.2d 1.
Ohio River Collieries Co. v. Commissioner, (1981), United States Tax Court · Docket No. 13483-78, 77 T.C. 1369.
Olson v. Schwartz, (1984), North Dakota Supreme Court, Civ. Nos. 10466, 10503, 345 N.W.2d 33.
Phillips Petroleum Company Iran v. Islamic Republic of Iran and the National Iranian Oil Company. (1989). IUSCT (Iran-US Claims Tribunal), Award No. 425-39-2. Also at:
Reeder v. Wood County Energy L.L.C., (2010), Texas Courts of Appeals, No. 12-08-00175-CV, 320 S.W.3d 433.
Repsol Sinopec Resources UK Limited V. OPRED, (2019), First-Tier Tribunal General Regulatory Chamber Environment, Appeal number: GGE/2019/0001/BEIS. At:
Rook v. James E. Russell Petroleum, Inc., (1984), Kansas Supreme Court, No. 54,031, 235 Kan, 6, 679 P.2d 158.
Stine v. Marathon Oil Co., (1992),United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, Nos. 90-2570, 91-2220, 976 F.2d 254.
T.W. Philips Gas & Oil Co. V. Jedlika, (2012), Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · No. 19 WAP, 615 Pa. 199, 42 A.3d 261.
Ware v. Stafford, 148 Cal. App. 2d 840 (1957), District Court of Appeal of the State of California. Civ. No. 22074. 148 Cal. App. 2d 840.
Other countries law and regulations:
Azerbaijan Shah Deniz PSA. (1996). At:
Brazil Concession Model (2008). At:
European Union Best Available Techniques Guidance Document on upstream hydrocarbon exploration and production (2019), Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg.
India Standing Committee on GIPIP (Good International Petroleum Industry Practices), (2016). At:
Fauna & Flora International (FFI). (2017). Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services: Good Practice Guidance for Oil and Gas Operations in Marine Environments. FFI: Cambridge U.K. Available from: www.fauna-flora.org
Iranian Petroleum Contracts, At:
Kurdistan Production Sharing Agreement model (2007). At:
Libyan The Petroleum Law. (1955). At:
Libya: Petroleum Law Amendment (Revision of Existing Concession Agreements). (1966). International Legal Materials, Vol.5, No.3, p. 442–461.
Libya Production Sharing Agreement IV. At:
Nigeria - Sao tome and Principe- Joint Development Authority- Model Production Sharing Contract (2004). At:
Tanzania Production Sharing Agreement model. (2013). At:
United Kingdom Petroleum Act. (1998). At:
United Kingdom Energy Act. (2016). At:
United Kingdom Infrastructure Act. (2015). At: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2015/7/section/41/enacted
United Kingdom Oil and Gas Authority, Stewardship Expectations Overview. (2019). At:
United Kingdom Oil and Gas Authority, (2020), Measurement Guidelines. At:
United Kingdom The Petroleum (Production) (Seaward Areas) Regulations, (1988), At:
)