Private Law Research

Economic Analysis of Proof of Causation in Environmental Torts

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

Hasan Badini 1
Farzaneh Motevaseliyan 2

1 Associate Professor, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran, Tehran, IRAN

2 LL.M. in Private Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran, Tehran, IRAN

https://doi.org/10.22054/jplr.2017.16270.1417
Abstract
One of the common difficulties in the field of environmental torts is the proof of causation between the tortious conduct of the tortfeasor and the damage suffered by the victim. This problem, according to the principles of economic analysis of tort law, results in denial of tort claims which itself, encourages the tortfeasor to externalize costs of his hazardous activities, dilutes his incentives to reduce environmental risks in an optimal way, and finally, disturbs the deterrent function of tort law. On the contrary, in recent decades, it is widely accepted that the preventive principle plays a crucial role in sustainable development. The importance of preventive approach in environmental policies requires the tort law –as one of the means of such policies –to serve the aim of deterrence as well as compensation. With these points in mind, this paper first clarifies the three main situations in which the proof of causation is problematic. It then tries to analyze possible solutions of those situations, using an economic perspective and to propose the most compatible solution with deterrence and efficiency, namely using the proportional liability in specific categories of environmental accidents.
 

Highlights

-

Keywords

Causal uncertainty
Economic analysis of tort law
Efficiency
deterrence
Indeterminate tortfeasor
Indeterminate Victim

-

-  Ben-Shahar, Omri, “Causation and Foreseeability”, in Michael Faure (ed.), Tort Law and Economics (Encyclopedia of Law and Economics, Vol. 1), Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2009.
-  Bentata, Pierre; Faure, Michael, “The Role of Environmental Civil Liability: An Economic Analysis of the French Legal System”, Environmental Liability, Law, Policy and Practice, vol. 4, 2012.
-  Cooter, Robert; Ulen, Thomas, Law & Economics, 6th ed, Boston: Addison-Wesley, 2012.
-  Faure, Michael, “Attribution of Liability: An Economic Analysis of Various Cases”, Chicago-Kent Law Review, Volume 91, Issue 2, 2016.
-  Faure, Michael, “Environmental Liability”, in Michael Faure (ed.), Tort Law and Economics, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2009.
-  Faure, Michael, “Regulatory Strategies in Environmental Liability”, in Fabrizio Cafaggi & Horatia Muri Watt (eds.), The Regulatory Function of European private Law, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2009.
-  Gilead, Israel; Green, Michael; Koch, Bernhard, “General Report, Causal Uncertainty and Proportional Liability, Analytical and Comparative Report”,in Israel Gilean, Michael Grenn, Bernhard Koch (eds.), Tort and Insurance Law, vol. 33, Berlin: De Gruyter, 2013.
-  Hinteregger, Monika (ed.), Environmental Liability and Ecological Damage in European Law (The Common Core ofc European Private Law), UK: Cambridge University Press, 2008.
-  Miceli, Thomas J, The Economic Approach to Law, California: Stanford University Press, 2004.
-  Moréteau, Olivier, “France: French Tort Law in the Light of European Harmonization”, Journal of Civil Law Studies, Vol. 6, Issue 2, 2013.
-  Oliphant, Ken, “causation in Cases of Evidential Uncertainty: Judicial Techniques and Fundamental Issues”, Chicago-Kent law Review, Vol. 91, Issue 2, 2016.
-  Posner, Richard A, Economic Analysis of Law, 6th ed, New York: ASPEN Publishers, 2003.
-  Sands, Philippe, Principles of International Environmental Law, 2nd ed, New York: Cambridge University press, 2003.
-  Schafer, Hans-Bernd; Ott, Claus, The Economic Analysis of Civil Law, UK: Edward Elgar, 2004.
-  Shavell, Steven, Foundations of Economic Analysis of Law, London: Harvard University Press, 2004.
-  Shavell, Steven, “Liability for Harm versus Regulation of Safety”, The Journal of Legal Studies, vol. 13, no. 2, 1984.
-  Sobczak, Faro, Liability for Asbestos-Related Injuries, Maastricht: Universitaire Pers Maastricht, 2013.
-   Thunis, Xavier, “Fonction et Fondement de la Responsabilité en Matiére Environnemental, Rapport belge”, in B. Dubuisson et G. Viney (eds.), Les Responsabilités Civiles Environnementales dans l’Espace Européen, Point de Vue Franco-belge, Bruxelles, Bruylant, LGDJ, 2006.
Private Law Research
Volume 7, Issue 27
Summer 2019
Pages 139-166

Main Page

Editorial Boards

Guide for Authors

Contact Us